Thoughts on Online Web Based DAW development

[Meesam-12321]

Hi guys! I am planning to develop an online DAW, since you guys are aware that most of such products are desktop based applications and my peers are raising questions on its feasibility on the web, because most of the plugins are written using c++ and there can be performance bottlenecks for a MERN stack based DAW, What do you think, should I give it a go?? Actually, if it was a hobby project then i wouldnt have thought much and just started without having feasibility concerns but since it is gonna be my FYP, I cant take chances. Because if I get stuck in an issue in the middle of development , then it would be wastage of alot of time and starting again would make it harder for me to meet the deadlines. What techstack do you guys propose?

[Rossmaxx]

Web is inherently slower for audio applications and afaik, realtime and web never goes hand in hand. There's this thing with audio that every sample should be processed 44100 times every second, so that might introduce lotta lag. There is an online daw named trackton waveform that i know of, but don't know the inner workings tho.

Anyway give it a shot. You'll learn a lot, even if the effort ultimately gets wasted, the learnings won't.

If you get stuck, feel free to ask here for help. Or a better place would be the discord server. It's easier to have a chat over there.

[YesImAsh]

cant we just use bandlab?

[softrabbit]

Shouldn't be impossible to make some kind of DAW using this:
https://webaudio.github.io/web-audio-api/#processing-model-background

[Cybernetic-Fox]

This is interesting! I'm not quite keen on browser DAWS, since (like Rossmaxx says, and my experiences with web-based DAWS) they can unintentionally introduce a huge buffer that heavily limits playback.

A tendency with browsers such as Google Chrome is that the processes within the web application can cause serious buffers depending on the user's device, introducing even more buffer/lag that minimizes capabilities and functions on large-scale projects.

I think you should strive and attempt to develop such a project because you may know how to combat this or learn how to improve what other web-based DAWS struggle with.

Softrabbit's source gives quite a unique view of processing!

This is only my thoughts based on my experiences :D

[Meesam-12321]

Thankyou very much for such a motivating reply. It is really a green signal for me to get started and when I actually become successful in the development of this product, this is gonna be the first place I am gonna share the outcomes. Again thanks!!!

[Cybernetic-Fox]

Of course! You're so welcome! :)

[SussyNavillus]

How long do you think this will take based on what you have rn.

[Meesam-12321]

I am just setting up things right now and learning through trial and error figuring out which approach would be the best. I came across web assembly and learned how it provides native level performance on the web. I will try to create some demo plugins and once they work fine. I will put my everything into it.

[SussyNavillus]

Did you get it working or are you still fixing problems