Redux Router VS React Router Redux

[yanivefraim]

It would be really interesting if you can tell about the decision of using Redux Router over React Router Redux.

I saw that you had an issue for using React Router Redux, and finally you chose the Redux Router.

Can you share your knowledge about this?
10x!

[sjmas]

I'm wondering the same thing. Some insight would be really helpful. redux-router's README has a comparison sections with some caveats, but ultimately says its advisable to use react-router-redux without really explaining why.

[brettdh]

I'm making the same evaluation right now and having the same difficulty.

I get the sense (possibly from something @gaearon wrote somewhere) that one big reason is that redux-router is not as well maintained. This twitter search is all I could find right now, though even the message from just that seems pretty clear (if unelaborated). Having the docs described in this issue will be a big help, I hope.

@yanivefraim the issue you link to actually discusses using redux-react-router, which became redux-router. There was also once redux-simple-router, which became react-router-redux.

[gaearon]

You don’t need either, why not just use React Router directly?

[gaearon]

(I wouldn’t suggest redux-router at all, and you only want react-router-redux if you want DevTools support.)

[brettdh]

Thanks @gaearon. I'm assuming you meant react-router-redux above (since that was the link target). This conversation was quite helpful for me in piecing this together. DevTools support does seem quite useful.

I was waffling for a while because of this caveat regarding router state in mapStateToProps (we have components deep in the tree that need to access location state). But I figure I can still use withRouter in that context and stop worrying about it.

[gaearon]

I was waffling for a while because of this caveat regarding router state in mapStateToProps (we have components deep in the tree that need to access location state). But I figure I can still use withRouter in that context and stop worrying about it.

Exactly.

[yanivefraim]

Thanks for the insights!

@gaearon - I would like to cease the opportunity and ask a (somehow related) question about Redux/React/Router. I already asked it here but did not get a proper answer...

In short:
It seems really strange to me that Redux state persists across page navigations (even that we are talking about single page application, I don't really see the difference). I think the while navigating to a url application state must be clean. And I can show several examples about problems with keeping state between navigations:

• User fills a form, and navigating to another page. When he navigates to this page again - do you want him to see the leftovers of what he had before? If not, you will have to take care of it manually.
• When a user navigates directly to a page inside your app (not from home page, lets say the user directly types a.html/page1/bla in his browser), is it reasonable that he would get a different results then a user navigating to same address from a different page (because he has different state...)

I would really love to hear your opinion about this.
Thanks!
Yaniv