You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
it honestly feels like a huge stretch to use authorization grant type for what is defined in this specification, given that:
client is authenticating the user/passing the info used to authenticate the user
a new endpoint
agree that there is probably no need for the new grant types per different authentication factors, but if you are defining a new parameter authorization_code, it is probably more honest and cleaner to define a new grant type to get an access token based on this new artifact from an authorization challenge endpoint. Security properties for the authorization code from a usual authorization endpoint and this new authorization challenge endpoint is also probably different, no? (I think I am slightly contradicting a comment in another issue #102, but a new grant type really feels better.)
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
I think the rationale (for me anyway) is that the goal is any existing OAuth authorization request can be made via the new endpoint (just like we didn't create a new grant_type for PAR). I'm not sure what the AS would do different for the request over a standard auth code flow? The goal is to return a code the client can use to request tokens as it normally does. This also keeps the models similar if the AS requires the user to go through a web flow.
it honestly feels like a huge stretch to use authorization grant type for what is defined in this specification, given that:
agree that there is probably no need for the new grant types per different authentication factors, but if you are defining a new parameter
authorization_code
, it is probably more honest and cleaner to define a new grant type to get an access token based on this new artifact from an authorization challenge endpoint. Security properties for the authorization code from a usual authorization endpoint and this new authorization challenge endpoint is also probably different, no? (I think I am slightly contradicting a comment in another issue #102, but a new grant type really feels better.)The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: