Cover states stays as Opening when issuing the open/up command

[hennikul]

I'm making a Zigbee device to control my garage door. I can control the device fine, all commands work, and state in Home Assistant updates as expected, except that sometimes when I click the "Up/Open" button, it's stuck in "Opening", even when it's 100% open. Sometimes it works though... If I use the position slider and set it to 100% open, it always changes state to "Open" when it's done.

After some googling, I have found other users experiencing the same behavior with other Zigbee Window Coverings, like from IKEA. One post somewhere suggested that the problem is target_lift_position not being updated before the command is issued to the device. This seems to be the case for me as well. It's updated when I use the slider, but when using the Up or Down buttons, it remains unchanged. The stop button seems to update it to the current position.

I guess that self._target.lift_position needs to be updated here:
https://github.com/zigpy/zha/blob/dev/zha/application/platforms/cover/__init__.py#L279
https://github.com/zigpy/zha/blob/dev/zha/application/platforms/cover/__init__.py#L294

Like it's done here:
https://github.com/zigpy/zha/blob/dev/zha/application/platforms/cover/__init__.py#L311

[puddly]

Does your device send attribute updates as the cover is opening? When it fully opens, ZHA should receive an attribute update like current_cover_position=0, indicating that the cover has been fully opened.

I believe this logic should handle it:

zha/zha/application/platforms/cover/__init__.py

Line 237 in ec12734

if position_or_tilt == 0:

[hennikul]

Yes, the device reports both current_position_lift (id: 0x0003, value: 0) and current_position_lift_percentage (id: 0x0008, value: 0) in the WindowCovering cluster (id: 0x102). These values have been verified in the administer Zigbee-unit GUI in Home Assistant when the cover is stuck in the Opening state after being fully opened.

[puddly]

Can you upload a debug log of it opening and getting stuck?

[hennikul]

ha_zigbee_up_command.log

I've uploaded debug log from HA from triggering the up command in the HA UI. State at the end is stuck in Opening.

[TheJulianJES]

Also seems similar to this issue:

• Cover states stays as Opening or Closing when using Set position #247