diff --git a/lib/puma_worker_killer/reaper.rb b/lib/puma_worker_killer/reaper.rb
index 25d943b..8dc9084 100644
--- a/lib/puma_worker_killer/reaper.rb
+++ b/lib/puma_worker_killer/reaper.rb
@@ -22,21 +22,26 @@ def reap
       @on_calculation&.call(total)
 
       if total > @max_ram
-        @cluster.master.log "PumaWorkerKiller: Out of memory. #{@cluster.workers.count} workers consuming total: #{total} mb out of max: #{@max_ram} mb. Sending TERM to pid #{@cluster.largest_worker.pid} consuming #{@cluster.largest_worker_memory} mb."
-
-        # Fetch the largest_worker so that both `@pre_term` and `term_worker` are called with the same worker
-        # Avoids a race condition where:
-        #   Worker A consume 100 mb memory
-        #   Worker B consume 99 mb memory
-        #   pre_term gets called with Worker A
-        #   A new request comes in, Worker B takes it, and consumes 101 mb memory
-        #   term_largest_worker (previously here) gets called and terms Worker B (thus not passing the about-to-be-terminated worker to `@pre_term`)
-        largest_worker = @cluster.largest_worker
-        @pre_term&.call(largest_worker)
-        @cluster.term_worker(largest_worker)
+        exceeded_memory = 0
+        to_kill = []
+        @cluster.workers.to_a.reverse_each do |item|
+          exceeded_memory += item[1]
+          to_kill << item
+          break if total - exceeded_memory < @max_ram
+        end
 
+        log_entry = "PumaWorkerKiller: Out of memory. #{@cluster.workers.count} workers consuming total: #{total} mb out of max: #{@max_ram} mb. " \
+          "Releasing #{exceeded_memory} mb from #{to_kill.length} workers."
+        to_kill.each do |item|
+          worker = item[0]
+          mem = item[1]
+          log_entry += "\r\n\tSending TERM to pid #{worker.pid} consuming #{mem} mb."
+          @pre_term&.call(worker)
+          @cluster.term_worker(worker)
+        end
+        @cluster.master.log(log_entry)
       elsif @reaper_status_logs
-        @cluster.master.log "PumaWorkerKiller: Consuming #{total} mb with master and #{@cluster.workers.count} workers."
+        @cluster.master.log("PumaWorkerKiller: Consuming #{total} mb with master and #{@cluster.workers.count} workers.")
       end
     end
   end
diff --git a/test/puma_worker_killer_test.rb b/test/puma_worker_killer_test.rb
index 4f87c08..93956d5 100644
--- a/test/puma_worker_killer_test.rb
+++ b/test/puma_worker_killer_test.rb
@@ -31,6 +31,7 @@ def test_kills_large_app
 
     WaitForIt.new(command, options) do |spawn|
       assert_contains(spawn, 'Out of memory')
+      assert_contains(spawn, /Releasing .* from 2 workers/)
     end
   end