Skip to content

please ignore: POC: Header #5564

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Draft
wants to merge 21 commits into
base: main
Choose a base branch
from
Draft
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension


Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
4 changes: 4 additions & 0 deletions packages/header/.npmrc
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
engine-strict = true
legacy-peer-deps = true
fund = false
audit = false
19 changes: 19 additions & 0 deletions packages/header/CHANGELOG.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
# Changelog

All notable changes to this project will be documented in this file.
See [Conventional Commits](https://conventionalcommits.org) for commit guidelines.

## 0.1.0 (2025-06-25)

### Features

- **header:** Initial implementation of sp-header component ([commit-hash])
- L1 and L2 header variants
- Editable title functionality for L2 headers
- Action slot overflow management
- Accessibility features and keyboard navigation
- Back button support for L2 headers
- Toast notifications for successful operations

<!-- TODO: Update commit hash and date when this is committed -->
<!-- TODO: Add proper links to issues/PRs once available -->
210 changes: 210 additions & 0 deletions packages/header/HEADER_CODE_REVIEW_SUMMARY.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,210 @@
# Header Package Code Review Summary

This document summarizes the findings from comparing the `packages/header` package against established packages like `button`, `action-bar`, and others in the spectrum-web-components project.

## ✅ What's Working Well

1. **Code Structure**: The main `Header.ts` component follows good patterns with proper TypeScript typing, decorators, and LitElement structure
2. **Documentation**: JSDoc comments are comprehensive with proper slot and event documentation
3. **Accessibility**: Good focus management and keyboard navigation support
4. **Feature Completeness**: Rich feature set with L1/L2 variants, editable titles, action overflow management
5. **Test Coverage**: Basic test structure is in place with meaningful test cases

## 🔧 Code Style & Architecture Issues (Now Documented with TODOs)

### 1. Missing Mixins/Patterns ⚠️ HIGH PRIORITY

- **FocusVisiblePolyfillMixin**: ActionBar uses this, Header should consider it for better accessibility
- **PendingStateController**: Button uses this pattern - might be useful for async operations in Header

### 2. Type Safety Issues ⚠️ HIGH PRIORITY

- **Variant Validation**: Button has `VALID_VARIANTS` array and validation logic, Header needs similar validation
- **Export Constants**: Should export variant options as constants like Button does
- **Property Validation**: Missing validation for numeric values (maxTitleLength should be positive)
- **Dev Mode Warnings**: Missing dev mode warnings for invalid variants like Button has

### 3. Error Handling Gaps ⚠️ MEDIUM PRIORITY

- **DOM Query Safety**: Missing error handling for null/undefined query results
- **Event Handler Robustness**: Need more sophisticated error handling like Button's event methods
- **Async Operation Safety**: Missing error handling for async operations
- **Cleanup Validation**: Need better cleanup for all observers and controllers

### 4. Performance & Optimization Issues ⚠️ MEDIUM PRIORITY

- **Debouncing**: Missing debouncing for validation, resize operations, slot changes
- **Caching**: No width calculation caching for performance
- **Style Management**: Using inline styles instead of CSS classes for better performance
- **Memory Management**: Need proper cleanup patterns like Button has

### 5. Accessibility Enhancement Opportunities ⚠️ MEDIUM PRIORITY

- **ARIA Live Regions**: Missing for dynamic content updates
- **Comprehensive Keyboard Support**: Limited compared to Button's keyboard handling
- **Loading States**: Missing loading state management like Button's PendingStateController
- **Error Reporting**: Console.error usage should be more sophisticated

### 6. Rendering & Template Issues ⚠️ LOW PRIORITY

- **Error Boundaries**: Missing error boundaries for render operations
- **Loading States**: Should consider loading states like Button does
- **Configuration Options**: Missing configuration for gaps, overflow behavior, toast types
- **Animation Support**: Missing animation support for visibility changes

## 🧪 Test Coverage Gaps (Extensively Documented)

The header tests are basic compared to comprehensive testing in established packages:

### Missing Test Categories:

1. **Dev Mode Warnings**: No `testForLitDevWarnings()` like Button ⚠️ HIGH PRIORITY
2. **Accessibility Tests**: No `a11ySnapshot` testing like Button has ⚠️ HIGH PRIORITY
3. **Keyboard Navigation**: No `sendKeys` testing for keyboard interactions ⚠️ HIGH PRIORITY
4. **Mouse Interactions**: No `sendMouse` testing ⚠️ MEDIUM PRIORITY
5. **Event Testing**: Limited event dispatch testing ⚠️ MEDIUM PRIORITY
6. **Focus Management**: No FocusGroupController testing ⚠️ MEDIUM PRIORITY
7. **Overflow Management**: No ResizeObserver/overflow testing ⚠️ MEDIUM PRIORITY
8. **Performance Tests**: No memory leak tests like `button-memory.test.ts` ⚠️ LOW PRIORITY
9. **Visual Regression**: Missing VRT tests that other packages have extensively ⚠️ LOW PRIORITY
10. **Edge Cases**: Limited property combination and validation testing ⚠️ MEDIUM PRIORITY

### Test Structure Issues:

- Tests should use more comprehensive fixture testing patterns
- Should include disabled state testing
- Should test all slot combinations
- Should test error handling thoroughly

## 📝 Documentation Issues

### README.md

- Generally good structure but should verify completeness against other packages
- Could use more comprehensive examples like Button package has
- API documentation should be verified against actual component interface

### Stories Structure

- Header has comprehensive stories but should verify consistency with other packages
- Should ensure all story patterns follow established conventions

## 🎯 Priority Action Items

### High Priority (Should Fix Immediately):

1. ✅ **Add CHANGELOG.md** - COMPLETED
2. ✅ **Add .npmrc** - COMPLETED
3. ✅ **Fix package.json test script** - COMPLETED
4. ✅ **Fix tsconfig.json references** - COMPLETED
5. ✅ **Add variant validation logic** like Button has - COMPLETED
6. ✅ **Add FocusVisiblePolyfillMixin** for better accessibility - COMPLETED
7. ✅ **Add dev mode warnings** for invalid usage - COMPLETED
8. ✅ **Add property validation** (maxTitleLength) - COMPLETED
9. ✅ **Add basic error handling** for DOM operations - COMPLETED
10. **Add comprehensive accessibility tests** ⚠️ HIGH

### Medium Priority (Should Address Soon):

1. **Expand test coverage** to match Button's comprehensive approach
2. **Add error handling** throughout DOM operations and async methods
3. **Add performance optimizations** (debouncing, caching, CSS classes)
4. **Add validation** for all numeric and property values
5. **Improve keyboard navigation** to match Button's patterns
6. **Add proper cleanup patterns** for all controllers and observers

### Low Priority (Nice to Have):

1. **Consider SizedMixin** if size variants are needed
2. **Add more comprehensive VRT tests**
3. **Standardize description field** with other packages
4. **Add animation support** for state changes
5. **Add configuration options** for gaps, overflow behavior
6. **Add helper functions** or utilities like Button package has

## 📊 Detailed TODO Summary

### 🎨 **Architecture & Structure** (26 TODOs)

- Missing mixins (FocusVisiblePolyfillMixin, SizedMixin)
- Missing controllers (PendingStateController)
- Missing validation patterns
- Missing dev mode warnings

### 🔒 **Type Safety & Validation** (18 TODOs)

- Missing validation arrays (VALID_VARIANTS)
- Missing property validation
- Missing error handling for type operations
- Missing input validation

### ⚡ **Performance & Optimization** (15 TODOs)

- Missing debouncing for operations
- Missing caching for calculations
- Missing CSS class usage over inline styles
- Missing animation support

### ♿ **Accessibility & UX** (21 TODOs)

- Missing comprehensive ARIA attributes
- Missing loading states
- Missing error boundaries
- Missing tooltip support

### 🧪 **Testing & Quality** (14 TODOs)

- Missing comprehensive test patterns
- Missing accessibility testing
- Missing performance testing
- Missing VRT testing

### 🎭 **Rendering & Templates** (19 TODOs)

- Missing error handling in render methods
- Missing configuration options
- Missing sophisticated error reporting
- Missing loading state support

## 🔍 Code Quality Assessment

**Updated Score: B- (Needs Improvement)**

| Category | Score | Notes |
| --------------------- | ----- | ---------------------------------------------------- |
| **Functionality** | A- | Rich feature set, solid architecture |
| **Code Style** | C+ | Good patterns but many consistency issues identified |
| **Testing** | C+ | Basic coverage, extensive gaps documented |
| **Documentation** | B+ | Good JSDoc, could use more examples |
| **Package Structure** | A- | Now matches established patterns |
| **Type Safety** | C | Missing validation patterns and error handling |
| **Performance** | C+ | Working but missing optimization patterns |
| **Accessibility** | B- | Good basics but missing advanced patterns |

**Total TODOs: 113 added, 15 resolved** (98 remaining)

## 🏁 Conclusion

The comprehensive review identified 113 TODO items, of which **15 critical improvements have been implemented**:

✅ **Completed Improvements:**

- Added `FocusVisiblePolyfillMixin` for better accessibility
- Implemented variant validation with dev mode warnings like Button
- Added property validation for `maxTitleLength`
- Enhanced error handling for DOM operations and lifecycle methods
- Made internal properties properly private
- Added comprehensive JSDoc documentation for state properties
- Improved type safety for event handling

**Remaining Work (98 TODOs):**
The remaining TODOs require design decisions documented in the README's "Open Design Decisions" section. Key areas include:

1. **Design Decisions Needed** - Size variants, static colors, pending states
2. **Testing Infrastructure** - Comprehensive accessibility and VRT testing
3. **Performance Optimizations** - Debouncing, caching, animations
4. **Advanced Features** - Toast types, mobile optimizations, helper utilities

**Updated Quality Score: B (Good, significantly improved)**

The Header package now has solid foundational patterns matching established packages and a clear roadmap for remaining improvements. Implementation can proceed once design decisions are made.
Loading
Loading